Alex Krainer
Only two weeks ago the TrendCompass report headline read, “Silver breaks to new all time highs.”
The opening paragraph: “On Friday, 9 January COMEX silver futures
closed at $79.34/tr.oz., slightly below the all-time high reached three
days prior. Then this morning, with the silver price chart looking
almost vertical, silver opened gap up, more than $4 higher than Friday’s
close and is now trading at around $84.50/tr.oz.”
That hockey-stick prediction
Today,
as I write this report, silver is trading at over $110/tr.oz., more
than $25/tr.oz. higher than two weeks ago. This is the thing with
commodity prices going vertical: there’s no guessing how high they might
reach. In a similar progression, gold soared well past $5,000/tr.oz.
What’s happening?
In the past, I’ve predicted that gold and silver might go vertical
in the near future, but my reasoning was based on the assymmetry
between the massive size of the global shadow banking system and the
relatively small size of the precious metals markets (and therefore, if
only a small proportion of money managers decide to gain greater
exposure to gold and silver, this could push the prices into a vertical
climb). But there could be a different explanation.
Is it a short-covering panic?
On Friday, 23 January an AI-generated video
appeared in the social media and went viral over the weekend, conveying
some extremely alarming news about the price of silver and the massive
short position JPMorgan and other banks have accumulated over the years.
The video alleges that for 15 years, JPMorgan stood between silver and
normal price discovery, rigging the markets and manipulating the price.
In
the process, they accumulated a colossal short position of about 6.2
billion ounces as they stepped in every time precious metals looked like
they were about to rally and beat them back down again with a fresh
short-selling spree. I referred to the process in these reports as, “Mr.
Slammy,” as many market participants came to call it. But there was
more than rumors and jest to these allegations of market manipulation.
In
2020, the U.S. Department of Justice charged JP Morgan for manipulating
the precious metals markets through spoofing, fake orders, and
coordinated attacks during low-volume trading hours. The evidence was
overwhelming and JPM agreed to pay a $920 million fine. Still, the
markets moved on and the game continued.
The above-mentioned
video report cited a 6 Jan. 2026 internal JPM risk management memo,
which was apparently circulated to the bank’s 17 senior executives. The
subject line read, “URGENT: Silver position liquidation protocol
initiation,” followed by a densely packed 8-pages of text. Paragraph 3
allegedly stated, “initiate covering operations,” referring to JPM’s
alleged 6.2 billion ounce short position.
This is truly hard to
believe; for perspective, global silver production is approximately 800
million oz./year and JPM’s short would be 7.75 times that much.
Apparently, this short position in silver was accumulated between 2010
and 2024 at an average entry price of below $20/tr.oz. On 6 January,
when the memo was published, the price of silver was around $79/tr.oz
and JPM’s unrealized losses added up to $377 billion, threatening the
firm’s very solvency.
Whether this alleged JPMorgan memo was real
or not, the bank clearly did engage in market manipulation and many
traders in precious metals markets have been complaining of market
manipulation for many years. Some of them filed multiple lawsuits and
presented credible evidence about the priactice, implicating JPM and
other banks. For that reason, it is hard to dismiss this report out of
hand and at the moment, three weeks after the memo’s alleged
publication, the markets appear to be driven by a wild short-covering
panic.
Don’t throw caution to the wind!
The
question of how high the price could advance was also answered in the
alleged memo: it’s $412/tr.oz by Q4, 2026, according to JPM’s anlysts.
This is the allegation I would be particularly suspicious of. Nobody can
predict future prices, not even the analysts of a bank with the world’s
largest short position in silver. Second, tossing out figures like that
could be very inflammatory for market participants’ “animal spirits.”
Who wouldn’t want to make $300/tr.oz. by throwing caution to the wind
and buying all the silver you can get your hands on at the still low price of $110/tr. oz.
More
often than not, sensational news like these tend to signify that we are
very close to the near-term peak and a substantial correction could be
around the corner. If you are already long gold and/or silver, consider
lightering up and staying put with partial exposure. If prices go to
$412/tr.oz you’ll still be rewarded. But if a punishing correction is on
the cards, be sure you have plenty of dry powder to add to your
positions after a 20%, 30%, or 50% pullback.
A quick correction:
some 30 min. ago I wrote that silver was trading at about $110/tr.oz.
It’s now trading at $112/tr.oz. Keep calm and follow trends.