New Zealand committed billions of dollars to climate programmes, international assistance and industrial decarbonisation. Yet a new international ranking places the country 47th for climate performance, down 13 places in three years. As hospitals struggle for investment and energy security remains a national concern, a larger question emerges: where did the money go, what did taxpayers receive, and could more of that capital have been invested in New Zealand's future?
eLocal Report: An independent examination of New Zealand's climate expenditure, government financial records, international commitments and the opportunity for a sovereign investment strategy. Incorporating reporting by Marc Daalder for Newsroom HERE.
Billions Committed. Questions Remain.
New Zealanders are repeatedly told that climate change demands urgent action, substantial public expenditure and long-term economic transformation. Governments have committed billions of dollars to emissions reduction, industrial decarbonisation, international climate assistance and programmes intended to prepare the country for a changing environment. These commitments have been made against a background of rising living costs, pressure on public services and growing concern about the reliability and affordability of electricity.
But what return have New Zealanders received from these investments? Have the programmes delivered the environmental improvements promised? Have they strengthened the economy, created productive national assets or improved the country's resilience? And, perhaps most importantly, who ultimately received the money?
These questions have become more pressing following a Newsroom report published on 16 November 2026, revealing that New Zealand has fallen for the third consecutive year in the international Climate Change Performance Index. The country now ranks 47th, down from 34th three years earlier.
A declining climate ranking does not, by itself, demonstrate that previous expenditure was ineffective. The index considers policy decisions as well as emissions and energy performance, while major infrastructure investments may take years to produce measurable results. Nevertheless, the combination of substantial financial commitments and disappointing international assessments provides a compelling reason to examine how public money has been used.
For eLocal, the central question is broader than climate policy alone. It is whether New Zealand is building lasting national wealth and security, or committing resources without adequately demonstrating the benefits.
The $4.5 Billion Question
In 2021, the Government established the Climate Emergency Response Fund, known as the CERF, with an initial allocation of $4.5 billion. The fund was linked to the scale of proceeds from New Zealand's Emissions Trading Scheme and intended to support initiatives that reduced emissions and improved climate resilience.
The figure is substantial. It represents capital that, if available for alternative investment, could support major infrastructure projects, medical research, energy generation or a long-term national investment portfolio.
However, the $4.5 billion was an initial funding envelope, not proof that the entire amount was spent. Treasury records show that the fund was subsequently adjusted and that it was closed at Budget 2024. Some previously funded initiatives continued through ordinary government appropriations, while others were changed or discontinued.
That distinction is essential. A responsible accounting must separate money announced, money appropriated, money contractually committed and money actually paid. It must also establish whether the expenditure produced assets or benefits that continue to serve New Zealand.
Treasury published financial and performance monitoring reports for CERF initiatives, including actual expenditure against funding baselines. Those records provide a starting point for tracing public expenditure, but they do not automatically identify every final contractor, shareholder or subcontractor who benefited.
If taxpayers are expected to accept extraordinary financial commitments, they should also expect extraordinary transparency.
Who Got the Money?
Some recipients are publicly identifiable.
The Government Investment in Decarbonising Industry programme, administered by the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority, provided co-funding to businesses undertaking projects intended to reduce fossil-fuel consumption and industrial emissions.
Among the largest announced partnerships were New Zealand Steel, with government co-funding of up to $140 million for an electric arc furnace at Glenbrook, and Fonterra, with co-funding of up to $90 million for fuel-switching and energy-efficiency projects at its processing facilities.
These were not simply unconditional cash distributions. They were co-investment arrangements associated with substantial private-sector expenditure, and the public amounts represent approved funding ceilings rather than proof that every dollar has been paid.
EECA reports that the two major partnership projects involved $230 million in approved public co-investment alongside approximately $860 million in private funding. Their projected emissions reductions are significant, although the ultimate results must be assessed as the projects are completed and operate.
There is an economic argument in favour of such investments. Modernising domestic steel production and reducing the energy costs of major food-processing facilities could help preserve employment, improve productivity and strengthen New Zealand industry.
But the existence of potential benefits does not remove the need for scrutiny. Would these businesses have undertaken the investments without government assistance? What financial return, if any, does the Crown receive? What contractual protections exist if promised outcomes are not achieved? And how much of the project expenditure flows to overseas equipment manufacturers and suppliers?
These are the questions that distinguish a genuine public investment from a subsidy whose benefits accrue disproportionately to private interests.
The answers require examination of contracts, payment records, ownership structures and independently verified results. The available public information identifies important recipients, but it does not yet establish the complete ultimate-beneficiary trail.
The Money Sent Offshore
A separate and particularly significant category is New Zealand's international climate finance.
In October 2021, Cabinet agreed to a $1.3 billion grant-based climate finance commitment covering 2022 to 2025. The programme was intended to help developing countries reduce emissions and adapt to climate-related risks.
Treasury documents show that $500 million of this commitment was drawn from existing international development funding, while $800 million was additional time-limited funding associated with the Climate Emergency Response Fund.
That means the $800 million must not be added to the original CERF allocation as though it were entirely separate expenditure. Doing so would risk counting some public funding twice.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade reports that approximately $813.2 million, or 61 percent of the $1.3 billion commitment, supported climate resilience in the Pacific. This included activities associated with energy, infrastructure, disaster preparedness, water security and other development priorities.
These are genuine international assistance programmes, not evidence that funds were secretly diverted or misappropriated. New Zealand also has strategic, diplomatic and humanitarian interests in supporting Pacific neighbours, particularly where infrastructure and disaster resilience are concerned.
Nevertheless, the commitment raises an important question about national priorities. At a time when New Zealand faces substantial domestic infrastructure needs, how should the Government determine the appropriate balance between international assistance and investment at home?
The fact that funding supports a worthy international objective does not eliminate its opportunity cost. Every dollar committed abroad is a dollar that cannot simultaneously be used to build a domestic asset, reduce public debt or strengthen New Zealand's own productive capacity.
That does not mean all international climate assistance should cease. It means the costs, beneficiaries, strategic rationale and measurable outcomes should be publicly available and regularly assessed.
A Ranking That Raises Questions
The latest Climate Change Performance Index adds another dimension to this debate.
As reported by Newsroom's Marc Daalder, New Zealand ranks 47th overall and has fallen 13 places over three years. Yet the same assessment ranks the country fifth for renewable energy, reflecting a comparatively strong performance in that category.
The sharp contrast lies in climate policy, where New Zealand was ranked fifth from the bottom. Environmental organisations contributing to the assessment criticised changes to methane targets, the Government's approach to fossil fuels and the effectiveness of the Emissions Trading Scheme.
Climate Change Minister Simon Watts challenged the index's credibility, arguing that it relied partly on assessments from organisations already opposed to the Government's policies. He maintained that emissions reductions, economic growth, jobs and affordable energy should be central measures of success.
Both positions deserve examination.
The index combines measured indicators with assessments of policy. It is not a financial audit, nor does a country's ranking reveal how effectively every climate-related dollar was spent. A policy change can affect the ranking before its longer-term economic or environmental consequences become clear.
Yet the report exposes an important tension. New Zealand has invested heavily in climate-related programmes while international campaign groups remain dissatisfied with its policy direction.
If additional spending does not guarantee an improved ranking, and rankings do not directly measure value for money, taxpayers need another standard by which to judge success.
That standard should include actual emissions outcomes, economic productivity, electricity affordability, infrastructure resilience and the lasting value of assets created.
What Did the Models Predict?
The financial debate also needs to be separated from the scientific one.
Climate models project future conditions under different assumptions about emissions, economic development and atmospheric processes. They are not all forecasts of what will inevitably happen. Some historical models have performed well against observed global warming, while others have overestimated or underestimated particular outcomes.
Extreme emissions scenarios have also been reassessed as energy systems, technology and economic expectations have changed. Revisions to the likelihood of a scenario do not establish that climate change is imaginary, but they do demonstrate why uncertainty and assumptions matter.
For governments committing billions of dollars, scientific uncertainty should be addressed through transparent economic analysis rather than ignored or exaggerated.
What assumptions were used to justify each major expenditure? What emissions prices, energy costs and future climate conditions were assumed? How sensitive were the projected benefits to those assumptions? And were competing investments assessed on equivalent terms?
A programme can be based on sound climate science and still represent poor economic value. Equally, a programme can deliver worthwhile energy-security or productivity benefits even if a particular climate projection later changes.
The public deserves to know which benefits were promised and which have actually materialised.
The Sovereign Alternative
New Zealand already has evidence that long-term public investment can build national wealth.
The New Zealand Superannuation Fund was established to invest on behalf of future generations. Its 2025 annual report recorded assets of approximately $85.1 billion and a 20-year annualised investment return of approximately 9.9 percent after costs and before New Zealand tax.
Those historical returns are not a guarantee of future performance, but they demonstrate the potential of disciplined, professionally managed investment over long periods.
Consider a hypothetical $4.5 billion investment earning an average nominal return of 5 percent annually, with returns reinvested. After 20 years, the portfolio would be worth approximately $11.9 billion before inflation, tax, fees and withdrawals.
This is an illustration of compound growth, not a claim that the entire CERF allocation could have been transferred into an investment fund or that the return would be certain.
A sovereign investment strategy could instead combine long-term financial assets with carefully selected investments in domestic productive capacity. These might include electricity generation and transmission, strategic fuel infrastructure, medical technology, research commercialisation and other assets capable of producing measurable economic or social returns.
Hospitals require a different financial treatment. They provide essential public services rather than conventional investment income, and their construction and operating costs must be funded accordingly. A sovereign fund could help support future healthcare expenditure, but spending its capital would reduce the amount remaining invested.
The objective would not be to pretend that every public service can generate a commercial return. It would be to establish a more deliberate connection between public expenditure, national wealth and the needs of future generations.
Energy Security Is National Security
New Zealand's energy position makes this discussion particularly urgent.
The country benefits from substantial renewable electricity generation, yet remains exposed to imported transport fuels, electricity supply constraints, dry-year risks and the costs of major infrastructure investment.
A sovereign energy strategy could examine investments in additional domestic generation, transmission capacity, storage, geothermal resources, strategic fuel reserves and technologies that reduce dependence on imported energy.
Such investments need not be in conflict with climate objectives. In many cases, improving energy efficiency or developing domestic renewable generation can reduce emissions while also improving security of supply.
The more important question is whether investment decisions are being made primarily to satisfy international policy expectations, or because they deliver demonstrable benefits for New Zealand households, businesses and national resilience.
The strongest projects should be capable of meeting both tests wherever possible.
A country that cannot reliably power its industries, transport essential goods or maintain critical infrastructure is economically vulnerable, regardless of its position on an international climate ranking.
Where Accountability Falls Short
The Office of the Auditor-General has examined how New Zealand's international climate finance is administered and how value for money is considered.
Its work highlights the importance of clear objectives, monitoring and evidence of outcomes. The existence of administrative reporting does not necessarily mean the public can easily determine the ultimate impact of each expenditure.
The same challenge applies domestically.
Funding announcements are often accompanied by estimates of future emissions reductions, jobs supported or investment attracted. Those estimates can be useful, but they are not equivalent to independently verified outcomes.
Taxpayers should be able to follow a major funding decision from Cabinet approval through the responsible agency to the recipient, the project and its eventual results.
For large projects, that should include disclosure of approved amounts, actual payments, procurement arrangements, material subcontractors where appropriate, expected benefits, delivery milestones and any subsequent changes.
If a project succeeds, the public should know. If it fails, the public should know that too.
The issue is not whether a recipient is a private company, an overseas organisation or a government agency. It is whether public money was allocated fairly, used lawfully and produced sufficient public value.
Does This Affect New Zealand?
Absolutely. The consequences extend well beyond environmental policy.
New Zealand faces competing demands for hospital capacity, medical research, housing infrastructure, transport networks, electricity investment and national energy security. Every major spending commitment involves a choice about what can be funded now, what must be postponed and what future generations will inherit.
Climate-related spending should therefore be judged within the same framework as other major public investments. It should not be exempt from rigorous economic evaluation because its stated objective is environmental protection.
Nor should investment in hospitals or energy security automatically be assumed superior without comparing costs, benefits, timing and risks. Some climate programmes may prevent future damage, reduce fuel costs or create valuable domestic infrastructure. Those benefits belong in the calculation.
But so does the alternative use of the money.
A government that commits hundreds of millions of dollars internationally should be able to explain why that expenditure offers greater national and strategic value than competing domestic priorities. A government that subsidises private industry should demonstrate why public assistance is necessary and what taxpayers receive in return.
And a government that relies on climate modelling to justify substantial expenditure should publish the assumptions, uncertainties and economic assessments underpinning those decisions.
Who Benefits? Who Pays?
There is nothing inherently improper about businesses earning revenue from climate-related investment. Engineers, manufacturers, contractors, researchers and electricity companies are all part of the economy, and profitable projects can deliver substantial public benefits.
The question is whether the balance between private gain and public benefit is appropriate.
When public funding supports an industrial project, does the Crown receive sufficient protection against cost overruns or underperformance? When equipment is imported, how much of the expenditure remains within New Zealand? When grants are made internationally, what independent evidence confirms their effectiveness?
And when consultants or advisers recommend programmes that create opportunities for their own industries, are conflicts of interest properly disclosed and managed?
These questions should not be confused with allegations of wrongdoing. Establishing that a business received funding is not evidence of corruption. Identifying foreign suppliers is not evidence that money was improperly transferred overseas.
But the public has a legitimate interest in knowing who benefits from policies funded through taxes, government revenue and the wider costs borne by households and businesses.
A Different Measure of Success
Perhaps the most important question is whether New Zealand has allowed international rankings and policy commitments to become substitutes for a clear national investment strategy.
The Newsroom report illustrates the problem. Environmental organisations consider New Zealand's climate policies inadequate, while the Government disputes the assessment and points to economic and energy-security priorities.
Meanwhile, taxpayers are left to evaluate billions of dollars in commitments through a complicated collection of Budget documents, agency reports and projected benefits.
What if the measure of success were more straightforward?
How much productive national wealth was created? How much more reliable did electricity become? How many businesses became internationally competitive? How much stronger is our infrastructure? What measurable environmental improvements were achieved? And how much capital remains available to future generations?
These questions need not replace emissions targets or international obligations. They should accompany them.
New Zealand can pursue environmental responsibility without abandoning fiscal discipline, and it can support its Pacific neighbours while remaining accountable for the domestic consequences of those commitments.
What it cannot afford is to treat expenditure itself as evidence of success.
Will This Make New Zealand Stronger?
The original $4.5 billion Climate Emergency Response Fund, the $1.3 billion international climate finance commitment and the major industrial co-investment programmes represent substantial public policy decisions. Their funding arrangements overlap in places, so they must not be casually added together to produce an inflated total.
Nor can their entire value be characterised as money sent offshore. Some funding supported New Zealand industry and infrastructure, while international assistance was directed principally towards developing countries, particularly in the Pacific.
Nevertheless, the scale of the commitments demands an accounting that goes beyond announcements and intentions.
New Zealanders should know how much was actually spent, who received it, what was delivered and what alternative investments were considered.
They should also be entitled to ask whether a larger share of future public capital could be directed towards sovereign wealth creation, healthcare capacity, research and energy security.
The objective is not to choose between protecting the environment and building a prosperous country. It is to insist that public policy does both wherever possible, and that spending which cannot demonstrate sufficient value is reconsidered.
Billions have been committed in the name of climate action. The responsibility now is to establish what those billions achieved, who benefited — and whether New Zealand could have built a stronger future with a different investment strategy.
Sources
- Newsroom — Marc Daalder, “Low-performing NZ drops in climate change rankings for third year in a row”, 16 November 2026
- New Zealand Treasury — Climate Emergency Response Fund and final monitoring reports
- EECA — Approved Government Investment in Decarbonising Industry projects
- Ministry for the Environment — Government partnership with New Zealand Steel
- MFAT — Climate Change Support
- MFAT — New Zealand's Climate Action in Our Region
- Office of the Auditor-General — Climate Finance Investment, Detailed Findings
- New Zealand Superannuation Fund — Annual Report 2025
- International Energy Agency — Government Investment in Decarbonising Industry Fund