An increasingly public disagreement has emerged between Washington and its European NATO allies over Ukraine's long-range attacks inside Russia. A senior Pentagon official has questioned the military value of strikes against Russian commercial infrastructure, warning that attacks intended to hurt the civilian population may be strengthening Moscow's resolve rather than bringing the conflict closer to an end.
INR Report: Based on reporting by RT, published 18 November 2026, HERE, with additional context from international reporting.
Pentagon Questions Ukraine's Strategy
A senior United States defence official has challenged Ukraine's campaign of long-range strikes against Russian commercial and civilian infrastructure, arguing that such attacks have produced little military benefit while potentially increasing Moscow's determination to continue the war.
Speaking at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group, US Under Secretary of War for Policy Elbridge Colby criticised what he described as attacks designed to inflict pain on the Russian population rather than undermine Russian military capabilities.
Colby singled out Ukrainian strikes against facilities belonging to Wildberries, one of Russia's largest e-commerce companies, as an example of a targeting strategy Washington believes has failed to achieve its intended objectives.
According to RT, the attacks formed part of a 40-day pressure campaign announced by Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky earlier this year. The campaign was intended to impose economic costs on Russia through strikes deep inside its territory, including against commercial facilities, energy infrastructure and maritime targets.
Colby argued that the attacks had neither brought the conflict closer to a negotiated conclusion nor significantly reduced Russia's ability to advance on the battlefield.
Strikes May Strengthen Moscow
The Pentagon official suggested that attacks against civilian infrastructure could be producing consequences opposite to those intended by Kiev.
Rather than weakening public support for the Russian government, he argued, the destruction of commercial facilities and disruption of civilian economic activity may be reinforcing public determination to resist Ukrainian and Western pressure.
Colby also warned that Russia could possess a greater capacity to sustain and escalate long-range strikes than Ukraine, raising questions about whether Kiev's strategy exposes its own infrastructure to disproportionate retaliation.
The comments represent a significant public criticism of Ukrainian military decision-making by a senior American official. They also highlight an important distinction between attacks intended to disrupt military operations and those designed primarily to impose economic or psychological pressure on an adversary's civilian population.
However, Colby's assessment of the campaign's effectiveness remains a US official's judgement rather than an independently established measure of its military impact. The precise status and use of individual facilities targeted by Ukrainian forces would also need to be established before determining whether particular strikes violated international humanitarian law.
Germany and Britain Push Back
The American criticism immediately exposed differences among Ukraine's principal Western supporters.
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius rejected the Pentagon's position, describing criticism of Ukrainian deep strikes as a stupid approach and arguing that Western governments should instead direct their objections towards Moscow.
British Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, who co-chaired the meeting alongside Pistorius, also defended Ukraine's freedom to determine its own military strategy.
The British position reflects the argument that Ukraine, as a country defending itself against Russia's invasion, must retain operational discretion over how it conducts the war.
Washington's concerns, by contrast, focus on whether particular operations are militarily productive and whether attacks against civilian infrastructure risk encouraging further escalation.
The disagreement does not necessarily indicate a wider collapse in NATO support for Ukraine. It does, however, reveal competing assessments of how Western-supplied military capabilities should be employed and whether economic pressure against Russian civilian targets can meaningfully alter the course of the conflict.
Civilian Targets Under Scrutiny
The controversy surrounding Wildberries illustrates the difficulty of distinguishing commercial infrastructure from facilities that may also contribute to military operations.
Ukraine has argued that the retailer supplies equipment and technical components used by Russia's armed forces, while Wildberries denies the allegation. These competing claims require independent verification. The existence of military-related supplies, if established, would be relevant to assessing whether particular facilities constituted lawful military objectives.
International humanitarian law requires parties to distinguish between civilian objects and military objectives. A commercial warehouse does not automatically become a legitimate military target because it operates within an adversary's economy. Equally, civilian ownership does not necessarily protect a facility if its actual use makes an effective contribution to military action and attacking it offers a definite military advantage.
The distinction matters because the broader conflict has involved repeated attacks on electricity networks, industrial facilities, transport infrastructure and other assets upon which civilian populations depend. Russia has conducted extensive attacks on Ukrainian cities and energy systems, while Ukraine has expanded its capacity to strike targets deep inside Russian territory. Both countries' operations remain subject to the laws of armed conflict.
The Cost of Escalation
RT reports that Russia has responded to Ukraine's pressure campaign by expanding attacks against Ukrainian infrastructure, including Black Sea ports and facilities supporting the country's metals export industry.
The Russian outlet links these developments to mounting pressure on Ukraine's economy, already affected by wartime labour shortages and mobilisation. However, the precise causal relationship between individual Ukrainian attacks and subsequent Russian operations has not been independently established in the material reviewed.
The broader economic consequences are significant. Ukraine depends on functioning transport corridors, electricity supplies and industrial production to sustain both its civilian economy and military operations. Damage to those systems can reduce export earnings, increase reconstruction requirements and deepen dependence on foreign financial assistance.
For Russia, Ukrainian attacks against oil refineries, logistics facilities and other infrastructure can also impose substantial economic costs. The central disagreement is whether those costs translate into meaningful military advantages or create further incentives for retaliation.
Western Funding Remains Central
Despite the disagreement, Ukraine's European supporters remain committed to additional military assistance.
At the Brussels meeting, Germany announced a $300 million contribution towards a weapons package coordinated with Norway, including Patriot air-defence interceptors. NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte also reported commitments exceeding $10 billion for purchases of American weapons for Ukraine through allied funding arrangements and related sales.
This highlights an important change in the Western support structure. Under President Donald Trump, Washington has shifted towards arrangements under which European and other allied governments finance purchases of American military equipment for Ukraine.
The arrangement maintains American defence-industry involvement while transferring a greater share of the financial burden to European governments and other partners.
It also raises a question about political influence. Governments financing Ukraine's military operations may have strong opinions about how those weapons should be used, yet European leaders are publicly defending Kiev's operational independence even when Washington questions its strategy.
Does This Affect New Zealand?
For New Zealand, the disagreement raises questions about the long-term costs and strategic objectives of supporting Ukraine.
New Zealand has contributed military training, financial assistance and other forms of support to Ukraine and has imposed sanctions on Russia. Although Wellington is not a NATO member, it maintains close security relationships with several governments directly involved in financing Ukraine's defence.
A prolonged conflict and continued attacks against energy infrastructure could contribute to volatility in international oil markets, shipping costs and insurance premiums. As an economy heavily dependent on imported refined fuels and international freight, New Zealand remains exposed to such disruptions, although the effect on domestic prices depends on wider market conditions.
There is also a wider diplomatic consideration. New Zealand has consistently supported the principles of sovereignty, territorial integrity and international humanitarian law. Those principles require the protection of civilians regardless of which party conducts an attack.
The emerging disagreement between Washington and European governments demonstrates that support for Ukraine does not necessarily imply agreement over every military operation.
For New Zealand policymakers, the distinction between assisting a country to defend itself and endorsing a particular targeting strategy remains important, especially when the consequences may include further escalation, greater civilian suffering and additional economic costs.
A Divided Western Strategy
The exchanges in Brussels have exposed a fundamental disagreement about the direction of the conflict.
Washington is questioning whether long-range attacks against Russian commercial infrastructure advance Ukraine's military objectives or simply encourage Moscow to intensify its response. Germany and Britain maintain that Ukraine must retain the ability to strike targets supporting Russia's war effort.
Neither position resolves the underlying question of how the conflict can be brought to an end.
The Pentagon's criticism nevertheless marks an important development: a senior American defence official is publicly challenging the strategic effectiveness of operations conducted by a government Washington has supported throughout the war.
For Ukraine, the challenge is to demonstrate that its military strategy can achieve meaningful results without exposing its population and economy to increasingly destructive retaliation.
For its Western supporters, the challenge is whether they can agree on a common objective beyond sustaining Ukraine's ability to continue fighting.
Sources