Two first-time National MPs are set to represent Papakura and Port Waikato following substantial preliminary election victories. Emma Chatterton leads Papakura by 8,394 votes, while Matthew Paul leads Port Waikato by 10,437. But the more revealing figures lie in the party vote. Both candidates attracted considerably more support than National itself, suggesting voters were making different choices about their local representatives and the political parties they wanted in Parliament.
A New Political Chapter for Two Electorates
The 2026 General Election has delivered a changing of the guard across two electorates central to eLocal's readership, with National candidates Emma Chatterton and Matthew Paul preparing to enter Parliament for the first time.
Chatterton leads in Papakura, while Paul has secured a commanding preliminary advantage in Port Waikato. Both electorates have returned strong candidate-vote results for National, even as the party's nationwide support fell below 30 per cent.
Yet the headline victories tell only part of the story.
A closer examination of the Electoral Commission's preliminary figures reveals a substantial difference between support for the individual National candidates and support for National as a political party.
That distinction is particularly important under New Zealand's Mixed Member Proportional electoral system, where voters have two votes: one for their local electorate representative and another for the party they want represented in Parliament.
In Papakura and Port Waikato, those two decisions produced markedly different outcomes.
Papakura: Emma Chatterton's Substantial Lead

Emma May Chatterton, National's candidate for Papakura, leads the preliminary electorate count by 8,394 votes. Image credit to be confirmed.
National's Emma May Chatterton received 16,118 electorate votes in Papakura, compared with 7,724 for Labour's Anahila Kanongata'a.
That gives Chatterton a preliminary majority of 8,394 votes, with all 91 preliminary voting-place results counted.
The remaining candidates were Angela Dalton of the Green Party with 2,621 votes, Malkiat Singh of ACT with 1,286 and Hannah Tamaki of Vision New Zealand with 470.
Chatterton's candidate vote represented approximately 57 per cent of valid electorate votes.
However, National's party vote was substantially lower.
National received 10,881 party votes, representing 37.87 per cent of the preliminary party-vote total reported by the Electoral Commission.
Labour received 8,097 party votes, followed by ACT with 3,422, New Zealand First with 3,097, the Greens with 1,844 and Opportunity with 901.
The difference is striking.
Chatterton received 5,237 more candidate votes than National received party votes, although those totals come from separate ballots and should not be interpreted as a direct transfer of votes between parties.
The figures indicate that Chatterton attracted support beyond the level recorded for National in the party vote.
They do not establish precisely which party-vote supporters backed her, but they demonstrate that the electorate result cannot be explained solely by National's party-vote strength.
Port Waikato: Matthew Paul's Commanding Result

Matthew Paul, National's candidate for Port Waikato, leads the preliminary electorate count by 10,437 votes. Image credit to be confirmed.
In neighbouring Port Waikato, Matthew Paul received 18,348 electorate votes, placing him 10,437 ahead of Labour's Matt Brachi, who received 7,911.
New Zealand First's Casey Costello received 4,334 candidate votes, followed by Green candidate Carl Morgan with 2,457 and ACT's Sarah Lochead-Macmillan with 2,456.
Paul received approximately 51.7 per cent of valid candidate votes.
National's party vote, however, stood at 13,486, or 37.76 per cent of the preliminary total reported by the Electoral Commission.
Labour received 7,333 party votes, ACT 5,692, New Zealand First 4,943, the Greens 2,360 and Opportunity 1,326.
Paul therefore received 4,862 more candidate votes than National received party votes.
As in Papakura, the difference suggests substantial split-ticket voting.
The electorate's voters gave Paul a clear preliminary majority while distributing their party votes among National, Labour, ACT, New Zealand First and other parties.
The result illustrates the distinction between choosing a local representative and choosing the political composition of Parliament.
Comparing the Two Electorates
The Electoral Commission's preliminary results reveal the following:
| Measure |
Papakura |
Port Waikato |
| National candidate |
Emma Chatterton |
Matthew Paul |
| Candidate votes |
16,118 |
18,348 |
| Labour candidate votes |
7,724 |
7,911 |
| National candidate lead |
8,394 |
10,437 |
| National candidate vote share |
57.1% |
51.7% |
| National party votes |
10,881 |
13,486 |
| National party vote share |
37.87% |
37.76% |
| Difference in vote share |
Approx. 19.2 points |
Approx. 13.9 points |
Source: Electoral Commission, preliminary results, 7 November 2026. Candidate shares are calculated from valid candidate votes; party shares are those reported by the Commission.
The similarity in National's party-vote support across the two electorates is noteworthy.
Despite different communities, voting populations and candidate contests, National received approximately 38 per cent of the party vote in both seats.
The candidate results were considerably stronger.
This is not evidence that voters necessarily rejected National's policies while supporting its candidates. The secret ballot does not reveal individual voters' combinations of choices, and differences in valid vote totals also matter.
But it does establish that the National candidates attracted a substantially greater share of candidate votes than the party received in party votes.
For the two incoming MPs, that distinction raises an important question about the nature of their local mandates.
What Happened to the Party Vote?
The Papakura and Port Waikato results also demonstrate the significance of smaller parties in the wider political landscape.
In Papakura, ACT and New Zealand First collectively received 6,519 party votes, equivalent to approximately 22.7 per cent of the preliminary party-vote total.
In Port Waikato, ACT and New Zealand First received a combined 10,635 party votes, approximately 29.8 per cent of the total.
These figures help explain why National's electorate candidates could receive outright majorities while National's own party-vote share remained below 40 per cent.
Support for centre-right parties was distributed across several political organisations rather than concentrated entirely with National.
At the same time, Labour remained the second-largest party-vote recipient in both electorates, receiving approximately 28.2 per cent in Papakura and 20.5 per cent in Port Waikato.
The Greens and Opportunity also attracted support, reflecting a broader distribution of political preferences.
The figures underline a central feature of MMP: an electorate can choose a National MP while contributing party votes to a wide range of parliamentary parties.
From Electorate Victory to Parliamentary Representation
For Emma Chatterton and Matthew Paul, the next challenge is a different one.
Winning an electorate provides a parliamentary mandate, but representing a diverse community requires engaging with constituents who voted for other candidates and parties.
Papakura includes established urban communities alongside growing residential areas and surrounding rural districts. Port Waikato encompasses communities with different local priorities, including Pukekohe, Waiuku and other parts of northern Waikato.
Both electorates face questions about infrastructure, transport, housing, employment, public services and the pressures accompanying population growth.
Their new representatives will be expected to work with central government while remaining accessible to local residents, businesses and community organisations.
The election results provide evidence of the support each candidate received. They do not, by themselves, establish how effectively either will represent their electorate.
That assessment will depend on their work in Parliament and their engagement with the communities they serve.
A Broader National Picture
The local results also need to be understood in the context of the nationwide election.
According to the Electoral Commission's preliminary figures, National received 29.21 per cent of the nationwide party vote, compared with Labour's 29.36 per cent.
Despite receiving fewer party votes nationally than Labour, National led in 42 electorate contests, compared with Labour's 21.
That distinction demonstrates the difference between electorate success and party-vote performance under MMP.
National's strength in individual electorate contests remains significant, but party votes determine the proportional allocation of parliamentary seats, subject to the electoral system's rules and any overhang.
For Chatterton and Paul, their local results represent strong individual mandates within a much more fragmented national political environment.
What Happens Next?
The preliminary results give both National candidates substantial leads, and neither electorate is among the closely contested seats awaiting the final count.
Nevertheless, the official results have not yet been declared.
Special votes, including votes cast overseas, are being checked and counted, while the Electoral Commission completes its recounting and verification processes.
The final figures may alter candidate totals, party-vote percentages and margins.
Once those results are available, eLocal will be able to examine the completed voting figures and the detailed results from individual polling places.
That will allow a closer look at the differences between Papakura township, the surrounding communities and the various towns and rural districts of Port Waikato.
For now, the preliminary election has delivered two new National representatives with substantial candidate-vote support.
But it has also revealed a more complex political picture.
Voters in both electorates have demonstrated that choosing their local MP and choosing their preferred political party are not necessarily the same decision.
That may be the most significant finding of all.
Sources
Electoral Commission — 2026 General Election
Editorial Note
This report is based on the Electoral Commission's preliminary results released following the 7 November 2026 General Election. The figures are indicative and remain subject to the official count, including special votes and verification procedures.
The official results are due 27 November 2026.
eLocal will review the confirmed results and update the report where necessary.