Alex Krainer
This year’s 62^nd^ Munich Security Conference was held from 13^th^ to 15^th^
February and it reaffirmed the splintering of Western alliance. Like
last year’s gathering, this year’s conference was marked by a growing
divergence between the United States and its European partners. While
the U.S. is seeking to change its foreign policy direction and embrace
multilateralism, European powers have remained fully committed to the
defense of the “rules-based global order.” Indeed, the Conference
acknowledged as much in its 123-page report, bizarrely titled, “Under Destruction.”
Ursula’s “true European awakening”
The
document recognizes Washington’s retreat from the rules based global
order, its wavering support for Ukraine and its threatening rhetoric on
Greenland, all of which exacerbates Europe’s sense of insecurity. On
Saturday, 14 February, European Commission President Ursula Von der Leyen
took the stage and spoke about “a strong Europe,” that has remained
“relentless and creative in the way we’ve maintained our support for
Ukraine.” She boasted about, “our €90 billion loan that Ukraine has only
to pay back if Russia pays reparations.” That, by the way, implies
Russia’s defeat in war, which further implies an indefinite continuation
of the war in Ukraine.
Furthermore, Frau von der
Leyen reaffirmed Europe’s commitment to a new arms race stating that,
“By 2028, defense investment in Europe is even projected to exceed what
the U.S. spent on such equipment last year. This is the true European
awakening. And this is only the start of what we need to do.” She said
that right after she invoked the one-for-all and all-for-one ethos: “It is our collective commitment to stand by each other in case of aggression. … And this is Europe’s meaning.”
Toward Europe’s Nazification?
And
how does Frau president propose to accomplish all that? “For the
answer,” she said, “I look to Ukraine. As they say in Ukraine, you
change or you die. We must adopt this mantra too. We need to tear down
the rigid walls between the civilian and defense sector. Europe is a
power house…” This was a strange and chilling rehash of another mantra
“they say in Ukraine” – back in 2022, Ukraine’s President Zelensky posed for a photo shoot in an olive green t-shirt emblazoned with a design that read, “Come to the dark side. Dominate or Die.”
Cosmetics
aside, von der Leyen’s pledge to tear down the rigid walls between
civilian and defense sectors is what should worry the ordinary
Europeans, because it implies repurposing the social programs, pensions,
health care, education and other benefits that European workers already
paid for in order to fund von der Leyen’s future warfare state. “We
have all agreed to spend more,” said von der Leyen, forgetting to
specify exactly who “we” is.
Who will pay?
However,
the hair in von der Leyen ointment is the €800 billion-plus money
problem: “Some ask whether we can afford this. But I say, we cannot
afford not to. And if we get it right – and we will,” promised Frau von
der Leyen, “we will turbo-charge a new industrial deal that will not
only keep us safe, but be an engine of growth delivering prosperity for
the Europeans for decades to come.”
But Von der Leyen’s show of confidence in Munich wasn’t backed up by the ECB President Christine Lagarde
who, for some reason, also spoke at the Conference. Ms. Lagarde herself
was surprised to find herself there: “It is a mark of how much our
world has changed that a central banker speaks at the Munich Security
Conference… A decade ago, this would have seemed like a category error.”
It was more than that: it was decades of compounding category errors.
The title of Lagarde’s speech was, “Preparing for Geoeconomic Fragmentation,” and its contents largely contradicted von der Leyen’s confidence game with statements like this:
- If
we pursue independence in sectors where we are lagging far behind, we
risk imposing costs that erode competitiveness downstream. For example,
pursuing full autonomy in chip making could produce what one study calls
“hollow champions” – firms unable to compete globally, supplying
substandard technology...
- Trusted partners do not always remain so.
- The
ECB needs to be prepared for a more volatile environment. … We must
avoid a situation where that stress triggers fire sales of
euro-denominated securities in global funding markets…
In a way, Lagarde’s remarks seemed to foreshadow monetary disorder,
just like the Council on Foreign Relations 1977 report did when it
recommended a “controlled disintegration of world economy.” In that
report, highlighted recently by Promethean Action’s Susan Kokinda in this superb video, Fred Hirsch
wrote that "a controlled disintegration in the world economy is a
legitimate objective for the 1980s." One year later, in 1978, Federal
Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker quoted that same phrase in a lecture at Warwick University.
“EUREP facility” is the new repo
In
fact, Lagarde admitted that the ECB has taken an active role in
European repo markets through ECB’s permanent EUREP facility, which is
an admission that Europe’s financial market is already broken, which
will eventually lead to monetary disorder. For the moment, the system is
kept aloft by large-scale liquidity injections from the central bank,
but this situation is unsustainable.
The seeds of monetary
disorder are already growing, well before von der Leyen’s ambitious
“ReArm Europe Plan” even took off in earnest. That dose of reality from
Ms. Lagarde indicates that there’s a deep abyss where Frau von der Leyen
is hallucinating a bridge and she is, in fact, pushing Europe into that
abyss.
The U.S. is charting their own way
Secretary
Rubio, who spoke less than an hour before Ursula von der Leyen, was
right to warn the conference’s attendees that his administration “will
not be polite and orderly caretakers of the West’s managed decline.”
If the 62^nd^
Munich Security Conference made one thing clear, it is that the
European war party is driving Europe down a road to nowhere. In the end,
any sensible leader in Europe will have to embrace that reality and
heed Secretary Rubio’s call to change course. Ultimately, that is a choice in the same way that the decades of managed decline were a choice, and it should be up to the ordinary Europeans to make.
Unfortunately,
that choice won’t be made before the monetary disorder. which will take
the form of high inflation and high interest rates, leads the European
Union and its political apparatus to its ultimate disintegration.