Immigration is emerging as a sharp dividing line in the 2026 election campaign, with ACT and New Zealand First advocating tighter controls while National, Labour and the Greens warn against policies they say could restrict needed workers or unfairly target migrants. The competing approaches raise a larger question: should immigration primarily meet immediate labour demand, or be managed against New Zealand's longer-term capacity to provide housing, infrastructure and public services?
eLocal Report: Based on reporting by Russell Palmer, RNZ HERE.
Immigration has moved firmly onto the election agenda, with New Zealand's political parties presenting sharply different views over how many migrants the country should accept, how permanent residence should operate and what should happen to people who remain in New Zealand unlawfully.
Speaking at the annual Immigration Conference in Auckland on Friday, representatives from ACT and New Zealand First argued for tighter controls, while National, Labour and the Greens warned against allowing concerns over population growth and infrastructure to develop into broadly anti-immigration policies.
New Zealand First leader Winston Peters has unveiled more than a dozen immigration proposals, almost all of which would restrict or more tightly control migration. ACT is also proposing significant changes, including tougher overstayer enforcement, stronger deportation provisions and changes to permanent residence.
National Questions How Restrictions Would Work
Immigration Minister Erica Stanford said National and New Zealand First were "very aligned" on immigration, but questioned how parties promising substantial reductions would determine which migrants should be excluded.
Stanford pointed out that nearly half of primary immigration applications are partnership-based, while many of the remainder involve workers required to address skills shortages. She argued that parties cannot simultaneously promise to attract the world's best workers while imposing substantial numerical restrictions without explaining who would no longer be admitted.
National also opposes ACT's proposal to abolish the existing permanent resident visa. Under ACT's proposal, migrants could remain in New Zealand indefinitely but would have to satisfy an ongoing physical-presence requirement.
ACT's Parmjeet Parmar told the conference that migrants would need to demonstrate they had spent 730 days, or two years, in New Zealand during any five-year period.
"People will be able to stay here indefinitely, but there is going to be a physical presence test ... people will have to show that they have been here in New Zealand for 730 days, which is two years, in [any given period of] five years."
Parmar said the proposal was similar to arrangements in Australia and Canada and argued that New Zealand's existing system was being abused by some people who obtained permanent residence and subsequently spent long periods overseas.
"I have heard many, many cases where people have gained permanent residency, but then have left New Zealand and haven't come back for very, very long time. I've also heard cases where people are coming back when they need our free or subsidised education system, or they need healthcare here to New Zealand."
Stanford rejected ACT's approach, saying permanent residence provides certainty to migrants who have demonstrated commitment to New Zealand and gives the country a competitive advantage when recruiting skilled workers.
"Our permanent resident visa provides certainty and stability for people who have demonstrated a commitment to New Zealand. It also provides that competitive advantage ... to attract skilled workers," she said.
She also argued that abolishing permanent residence could create a difficult choice for migrants from countries that do not permit dual citizenship, potentially forcing them to choose between New Zealand citizenship and retaining the nationality of their country of origin.
Labour and Greens Reject Anti-Immigration Framing
Labour immigration spokesperson Phil Twyford used much of his speech to condemn what he described as a "dumpster fire" of right-wing populism that demonised migrants and refugees.
Labour has proposed its own immigration changes, including a pathway to citizenship for children born in New Zealand to undocumented parents, a longer process for obtaining permanent residence and a review of financial criteria applying to parent visas.
Green Party immigration spokesperson Ricardo Menendez March similarly rejected arguments that migration was responsible for New Zealand's broader economic and infrastructure problems.
"In our country we face a huge amount of challenges: we have an infrastructure deficit, an ageing population, we have low wages compared to other comparable nations, we have a tax system that overtaxes work while it doesn't really want to touch wealth."
"None of these issues were caused by migrant workers, and none of these issues will be addressed by throwing dog whistles on getting tough on immigration, or extending the time that it takes for someone to become a permanent residency."
The Greens are proposing a "settled residency pathway" allowing people who have lived in New Zealand for five years to obtain residence. The party would also end 12-month stand-down periods requiring some migrant workers to leave the country between visas and would allow migrant workers greater freedom to change employers.
The Overstayer Divide
How to deal with people already living unlawfully in New Zealand exposes another significant division between the parties.
The Greens support an amnesty or regularisation programme. Menendez March said there were around 20,000 overstayers in New Zealand, many of whom were already working and paying tax, meaning granting them legal status would not suddenly add the same infrastructure pressure as bringing an equivalent number of new migrants into the country.
"A regularisation programme won't add significant infrastructure pressures considering the people are already here, many of them are already working, many of them are already paying tax."
National's Stanford disagrees. She criticised both Green and New Zealand First proposals for Pacific overstayer amnesties, arguing that repeated regularisation programmes risk creating an expectation that remaining unlawfully in New Zealand long enough may eventually produce a pathway to legal residence.
"What they do fuel is the next generation of overstayers who think if they wait long enough they will have a pathway to residence or a valid visa."
ACT is proposing the opposite approach, with a dedicated overstayer enforcement unit within Immigration New Zealand and stronger deportation laws.
Parmar framed the issue as one of fairness to migrants and employers who follow the law.
"If somebody works illegally the lawful migrant who paid the fee and met the requirements is being undercut. If an employer exploits workers every responsible employer is forced to compete against someone who has decided the rules do not matter."
"That's why we have proposed a dedicated unit to deal with overstayers."
The Bigger Question: How Many People Can New Zealand Sustain?
Behind the competing policies is a question that extends beyond whether New Zealand is "pro" or "anti" immigration.
Immigration provides businesses with workers, reunites families, attracts skills and contributes to economic activity. But population growth also increases demand for housing, transport, hospitals, schools, electricity, water infrastructure and other public services. The policy challenge is therefore not simply whether immigration is desirable, but whether the rate and composition of migration are aligned with the country's capacity to absorb population growth.
That distinction is important because criticism of immigration policy is not necessarily criticism of immigrants themselves. Governments determine visa settings and migration numbers. Migrants respond to the opportunities and rules those governments establish.
Likewise, tighter immigration controls do not automatically resolve New Zealand's productivity, infrastructure or skills problems. Reducing access to migrant labour without increasing domestic skills, investment and productivity could simply transfer shortages elsewhere in the economy.
The election debate therefore requires more than competing accusations of being either anti-immigrant or soft on immigration. Voters need to know what population level each party's policies are likely to produce, what skills New Zealand needs, what infrastructure that population requires, and how those services will be funded.
New Zealand's immigration system ultimately serves two groups whose interests should not be treated as mutually exclusive: the people already living here and those invited to build their lives here.
The question for the 2026 election is whether the parties can move beyond political labels and demonstrate that their immigration settings are part of a coherent long-term plan for population, productivity, infrastructure and New Zealand's national interest.
Source
Russell Palmer, RNZ, ACT and NZ First pitch tighter immigration controls, others warn against anti-immigration policies:
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/1340334/act-and-nz-first-pitch-tighter-immigration-controls-others-warn-against-anti-immigration-policies
Independent reporting. Original context. Credited sources.