The Green Party's latest tax proposal is being marketed as a solution to inequality. I see it differently. I see it as envy dressed up as economic policy. A wealth tax. An inheritance tax. Higher corporate taxes. More levies on productive enterprise. More government intervention into the lives and assets of people who have spent decades building businesses, creating jobs, taking risks and generating prosperity.
The question New Zealanders should be asking is simple:
Where has this ever worked?
History is littered with examples of governments believing they can tax a nation into prosperity. The results are almost always the same. Capital leaves. Investment slows. Productivity falls. Opportunity shrinks. The people who can leave, do leave. The people who can't, pay the price.
The Greens call it fairness.
I call it punishment.
The Real Problem Nobody Wants To Discuss
New Zealand does not have a wealth problem.
New Zealand has a productivity problem.
We have an economy that increasingly struggles to reward effort, skill, innovation and risk-taking.
We have a generation of young people leaving our shores in record numbers because they see greater opportunities elsewhere.
We have businesses struggling with compliance costs, energy costs, labour shortages and regulatory burdens.
We have workers who often find that after tax, accommodation costs and inflation, there is little left at the end of the week.
Yet somehow the answer from the Greens is always the same:
Tax more.
Take more.
Redistribute more.
Blame somebody else.
At no point do they seem willing to confront the uncomfortable reality that prosperity must first be created before it can be redistributed.
The Inheritance Tax Is Particularly Offensive
Perhaps the most disturbing proposal is the inheritance tax.
Think about what this really means.
Parents work their entire lives.
They pay income tax.
They pay GST.
They pay rates.
They pay fuel taxes.
They pay company taxes.
They pay countless hidden taxes embedded throughout the economy.
Then after a lifetime of sacrifice, saving and planning, they want to leave something behind for their children and grandchildren.
The Green Party says the government deserves another cut.
Why?
Why should the state have a greater claim on a family's legacy than the family itself?
What moral authority gives politicians the right to confiscate the fruits of one generation's labour before passing them to the next?
This is not fairness.
It is state-sanctioned confiscation.
Taxing Success Creates Less Success
The Greens repeatedly target those they describe as "the wealthy".
But who exactly are these people?
Business owners.
Farmers.
Investors.
Entrepreneurs.
Professionals.
People who took risks when others wouldn't.
People who created businesses that employ New Zealanders.
People who built productive assets rather than consuming everything they earned.
Every successful economy in history has relied upon people willing to invest, innovate and build.
Every struggling economy eventually reaches the point where productive people decide the effort is no longer worth the reward.
New Zealand is already experiencing one of the greatest brain drains in modern history.
Talented young people are leaving for Australia, Asia, Europe and North America.
The answer surely cannot be to make New Zealand even less attractive for investment and enterprise.
What About Real Solutions?
If the Greens were genuinely serious about improving living standards, they would be talking about productivity.
They would be talking about energy sovereignty.
They would be talking about banking reform.
They would be talking about infrastructure.
They would be talking about vocational education, apprenticeships and skilled trades.
They would be talking about removing barriers that stop businesses growing and employing more people.
They would be talking about affordable housing supply rather than endless regulation.
They would be talking about creating wealth, not redistributing it.
Instead, we get another round of class warfare politics.
The rich versus the poor.
Workers versus business owners.
Success versus resentment.
It is divisive, tired and intellectually lazy.
The Prosperity Question
The fundamental question remains unanswered.
Will these taxes improve education outcomes?
Will they improve healthcare?
Will they increase productivity?
Will they lift wages?
Will they encourage investment?
Will they stop the exodus of talented New Zealanders?
Will they make New Zealand more competitive internationally?
There is little evidence to suggest they will.
What they will do is send another message to productive New Zealanders that success is something to be penalised rather than celebrated.
Time For Leadership
New Zealand does not need more politics of envy.
It does not need more division.
It does not need more attacks on people who create businesses, jobs and opportunities.
It needs leadership.
It needs vision.
It needs policies that grow the economic pie rather than endlessly arguing about how to divide it.
Most importantly, it needs politicians who understand that prosperity is created by productive people, not by governments redistributing the proceeds.
If political parties cannot offer realistic, productive policies that improve the lives of all New Zealanders, then they should step aside and allow those with genuine solutions to lead.
Because the road New Zealand is currently travelling is already producing a record brain drain, declining productivity and rising dependency.
And if we continue down that path, the warning may become reality:
Last one out, turn off the lights.
This opinion was prompted by the Green Party's 2026 tax policy announcement proposing wealth, inheritance and increased corporate taxes.