Christopher Luxon's latest KiwiSaver announcement is being promoted as a plan to help New Zealanders build wealth and retire with greater financial security. On the surface, it sounds sensible. Who wouldn't want larger retirement savings?
Who wouldn't want greater financial independence in later life?
But beneath the headlines sits a deeper question that politicians rarely ask:
At what point does encouragement become compulsion?
And perhaps more importantly:
Who should be paying for it?
The Slow March Towards Compulsory Saving
When KiwiSaver was introduced in 2007, it was sold as a voluntary savings scheme.
The principle was straightforward. New Zealanders could choose to participate and build retirement savings with the assistance of government incentives and employer contributions.
Choice was the key word.
Now National is proposing compulsory participation for every worker from 2028.
In effect, KiwiSaver ceases to be a voluntary savings scheme and becomes another mandatory deduction from a worker's income.
The reality is that many New Zealanders are already struggling with mortgages, rent, food prices, insurance premiums, rates, fuel costs and taxes.
Some would prefer to save through KiwiSaver.
Others may prefer to pay down debt.
Others may wish to invest directly.
Others may need every dollar available simply to get through the week.
Why should politicians decide that one financial strategy is superior to all others?
The irony is that compulsory savings are still not wealth creation.
They are merely forced allocation.
Why Is It Business's Responsibility?
One aspect of the proposal receives surprisingly little scrutiny.
Employer contributions.
Every KiwiSaver contribution made by an employer comes on top of wages already paid.
Businesses are expected to fund a portion of an employee's personal retirement savings.
Why?
Since when did retirement planning become the responsibility of employers?
Businesses already pay wages.
They already pay ACC levies.
They already pay payroll costs.
They already navigate increasing compliance burdens, health and safety obligations, employment law requirements, leave entitlements and taxation.
Now we are told they should continue funding retirement savings indefinitely.
The uncomfortable reality is that businesses do not create money from thin air.
Every additional compulsory cost is ultimately absorbed somewhere.
Higher prices.
Reduced hiring.
Lower wage growth.
Reduced investment.
Or smaller profits that would otherwise be reinvested into expansion and job creation.
Politicians love announcing benefits.
Business owners are left paying for them.
The Over-65 Proposal Makes Little Sense
The proposal requiring employers to continue KiwiSaver contributions for workers over 65 is particularly puzzling.
The argument appears to be that because more New Zealanders are working beyond retirement age, they should continue receiving employer KiwiSaver contributions.
But why are so many people working beyond 65 in the first place?
Perhaps because the cost of living continues to rise faster than retirement incomes.
Perhaps because housing costs have exploded.
Perhaps because many retirees simply cannot afford not to work.
The answer to that problem is not necessarily another obligation placed upon employers.
It may be time to ask a more fundamental question.
Should New Zealand Superannuation itself be more generous?
And should it be entirely tax free?
Pensioners Built This Country
Many of today's retirees spent decades paying taxes.
Income tax.
GST.
Rates.
Fuel taxes.
Excise taxes.
Company taxes.
Inflation taxes through monetary debasement.
A lifetime of contributions.
Yet when they finally reach retirement age, the state continues taxing their pension payments.
That strikes many New Zealanders as fundamentally unfair.
If politicians are genuinely concerned about retirement security, perhaps they should focus on ensuring retirees can live with dignity and independence rather than creating new layers of compulsory contributions.
The Baby Bonus Question
The proposal to automatically enrol every newborn child into KiwiSaver and provide a $1,500 government contribution may be politically attractive.
But governments do not generate wealth.
Taxpayers do.
Every dollar placed into a newborn's KiwiSaver account must first be extracted from someone else's income.
There is no free money.
Only transferred money.
The real question is whether governments are becoming increasingly comfortable directing how citizens save, invest and allocate their own resources.
New Zealand's Bigger Problem
Retirement savings matter.
But KiwiSaver is not New Zealand's biggest economic challenge.
Our productivity is weak.
Our infrastructure is strained.
Energy costs are rising.
Housing remains unaffordable for many younger families.
Business investment remains sluggish.
Skilled workers continue leaving the country in large numbers.
These are the issues that determine long-term prosperity.
No amount of compulsory savings can compensate for an economy that is failing to generate sufficient growth.
Freedom Matters
The underlying issue is not whether KiwiSaver is a good scheme.
For many people, it undoubtedly is.
The issue is whether participation should remain a personal choice.
Whether businesses should be forced to fund personal retirement plans.
Whether government should increasingly direct individual financial decisions.
And whether politicians are addressing symptoms rather than causes.
A prosperous nation is built by productive businesses, skilled workers, strong families and economic freedom.
Not by endlessly expanding compulsory schemes and obligations.
New Zealand needs more wealth creation.
Not more compulsion.